9/11: Unanswered, Part Seven: The Fifth Plane – EP 171
9/11: Unanswered, Part Seven: The Fifth Plane
Eric calls this one close to a bonus episode: a couple more stories to round out the series before the final takes. The count everybody knows is four planes and 19 men, the number in the 9/11 Commission report. But in the fall of 2001, Newsweek reported a theory widely held inside law enforcement that there had been five hijacking teams, not four. It faded within months, and Eric says he only brought it to the show because of who is telling it: a captain and his flight crew, people the guys feel they have to hear out.
The fifth plane is United Flight 23, a Boeing 767 booked from JFK to Los Angeles with about 160 passengers, stuck in a line of jets around 9 a.m. when the airport froze. After a United dispatcher’s warning to “beware any cockpit intrusion” came through, the captain grabbed the crash axe and the first officer wedged suitcases against the door, since cockpit doors in 2001 were not reinforced. Three flight attendants, speaking most fully on camera in 2023, describe four first class passengers: two men, a young boy and a figure in a burqa whose hands looked to them like a man’s, a group that refused food, kept asking to just take off, and turned up at the cockpit door after being told no. The guys push back hard: people fly with kids, everybody sweats on a parked plane, asking whether they got the White House was a logical guess once the Pentagon was hit, and all of it was remembered after the crew knew what happened that day.
The flight never took off. It went back to a gate, was emptied and locked, and the story gets thinner from there. One flight attendant who asked not to be named says she went back aboard for a water bottle and found two men hiding in the rear galley, who she was later told slipped out through a floor hatch into the electronics bay; the guys flag it as a single uncorroborated account. Add a report of men refusing to leave a canceled flight at the gate, four Saudi men reportedly detained at JFK two days later and, by the captain’s account, released once investigators decided they were not involved, and a call telling the captain box cutters had turned up on the 767 parked next to his. His own read is that someone on the ground planted them on the wrong plane. The hosts ask why an insider would plant box cutters instead of guns, and note that every extra helper makes a plot easier to break.
The paper trail is what keeps it alive. In 2002 NORAD’s deputy commander said the military suspected more than four aircraft might have been involved, and in 2004 an Illinois congressman said the suspicious passengers were never found, yet the 9/11 Commission’s final report never mentions Flight 23. A 2008 book reported box cutters and al Qaeda instruction sheets in unclaimed luggage, never officially confirmed, and a 2023 TMZ documentary put the crew on camera, with the captain saying he believes it more likely than not that his was the fifth plane. The guys knock TMZ as tabloid and call most of it loose. What moves them is the FBI’s July 2023 reply to Florida Bulldog: it holds records on Flight 23 but will not release them, citing a pending or prospective law enforcement proceeding. Their verdict lands between hindsight and that open file, and one host floats, purely as speculation, that extra teams could have been a planned backup.
The last story is Zacarias Moussaoui, the one man tied to the plot whom the government caught in advance. A French citizen with no pilot’s license, he paid $6,800 in cash for Boeing 747 simulator training in Minnesota, the school called the FBI, and he was arrested on August 16, 2001 for overstaying his visa. FBI headquarters decided there was not enough for a warrant to search his laptop, and one came through only on the afternoon of 9/11; the Commission wrote that a maximum effort conceivably could have led investigators to the core of the plot. He pleaded guilty to six conspiracy counts in 2005 while denying a role in 9/11 itself, testified in 2006 that he and shoe bomber Richard Reid were meant to fly a fifth plane into the White House, and later called that a complete fabrication. The jury did not agree on death, and he is serving life without release, the only person convicted in a US court in connection with 9/11. The guys speculate he was a low level player chasing clout and wonder whether the government simply needed a conviction. Next up is Part 8, the final summations, where each host gets the floor, unargued, to say what he thinks happened.
- United Flight 23 was a Boeing 767 scheduled to leave JFK for Los Angeles around 9 a.m. on September 11 with about 160 passengers; after a United dispatcher’s message to “beware any cockpit intrusion,” the captain took up the crash axe and the first officer wedged suitcases against the unreinforced cockpit door
- Flight attendants, on camera together in a March 2023 TMZ documentary, described four first class passengers, two men, a boy and a figure in a burqa they believed was a man, who refused food and pressed to take off; the flight never left the ground and those passengers have never been publicly identified
- In 2002 NORAD’s deputy commander said the military suspected there might have been more than four aircraft involved, and in 2004 an Illinois congressman said the suspicious passengers were never found; the 9/11 Commission’s final report does not mention Flight 23
- In July 2023 the FBI told Florida Bulldog it holds records on Flight 23 but withheld them, writing that “there is a pending or prospective law enforcement proceeding relevant to these responsive records”
- Zacarias Moussaoui paid $6,800 in cash for Boeing 747 simulator training in Minnesota with no pilot’s license and was arrested on an immigration violation on August 16, 2001; agents got a criminal warrant for his belongings only on the afternoon of 9/11, and the 9/11 Commission said a maximum effort conceivably could have led investigators to the core of the plot
- Moussaoui pleaded guilty to six conspiracy counts in April 2005, testified in March 2006 that he and shoe bomber Richard Reid were to fly a fifth plane into the White House, then called that testimony a complete fabrication; he is serving life without release at the federal supermax in Colorado, the only person convicted in a US court in connection with 9/11
Read the full transcript
Hey guys, welcome back to the Conspiracy Podcast. Yo yo, my name is Eric. This is Jorge and Sean. Hope you guys are doing well. Welcome to This is like bonus episode really in terms of like our I’m sure this is going to piss people off. Chris Chris with a K is going to be furious [laughter] that we haven’t ended it yet. But there’s just a couple more stories that will round out our 911 series and this is that episode. And um but before we do, yeah, we do the patrons. And once again, Chris is going to be furious. Um Chris with a K knows who he is.
We love you still. So rattle these off quickly. We’ve got Afton M with a yearly. We got Katie M. We got Bill S. We got Nikki with Nikki with a KK K. The K is her last name. She’s the Discord. Nikki. And you are a girl. Eric will not make that mistake again. [laughter] Then we got Tim B with a inner circle yearly, my guy. We got Haley B. We got Sarah KP. I can’t say your last name. And then we’ve got Katherine EP with a yearly inner circle. Katherine, I love you. And then last but certainly not least, we’ve got Melanie P. We love you guys.
So, if you wanted to support the show, if you like the show, if you consume content on the show, go to patreon.com/theconspiracy podcast. So, what do we got on the deck of today? So, this one, when Eric was bringing up, I weard of I’ve never heard I really have never heard of this. Yeah. Also, as a disclaimer, if you are joining us now, you should go back to the beginning of our 911 series. Yes, please. Yeah, cuz we’ve gone over a lot of different things. do something. Um, four planes, 19 men. That’s the number everybody knows. That’s the number in the 9/11 Commission report. That’s the number in our history books.
The number that’s been repeated so many times over the last 25 years. Four planes on 9/11. Except in the first 48 hours after the attacks, before anybody had settled on a clean story, that wasn’t the number law enforcement was actually working with. In the fall of 2001, Newsweek reported what it called a widely held theory inside law enforcement that there hadn’t been four hijacking teams on September 11th. There were five. Yeah. So weird. I I can’t believe I’ve never heard of this. Yeah. And the fifth one, for whatever reason, never really gained its footing as a theory, but here is that theory. Perfect. Within a couple months, the FBI had moved on, settled on different suspects for the empty seat on flight 93.
Do you remember this? That flight 93 had one less hijacker. Yeah, exactly. Oh, yeah. Because there was Yeah. Yeah. We then we did the numbers and we’re like, “Oh, okay. What?” And then wasn’t that that guy got like arrested? He didn’t He was deported straight out of Orlando ahead of time. So, he just never made it. So, instead of 20 hijackers, there was 19. There was 19. And you know, we had brought up previously that it’s possible that the lack of muscle on United Nations allowed them to be overcome. That’s right. Yeah. So, I’m not saying that’s only the only reason. Yeah. But it could have been a contributing factor potentially.
Exactly. Yeah. Exactly. So, that theory didn’t stay the official line for long. Within a couple of months, the FBI had moved on. They settled on different suspects for the empty seat on Flight 93. And the idea of a fifth plane quietly dropped out of the public conversation, but it never fully died. It just went underground. It got picked up by investigators, by journalists, and by actually the flight crew of the fifth plane. And the only reason why I really put this as an episode is because of the flight crew. I wouldn’t have done it if it was a super fringe theory. Yeah. an outrageous, you know what I mean?
Like just a wild thing, deep Reddit hole. But you’re going to learn that it’s the witnesses are a captain and two flight crew. Okay. So, the theoretically respectable humans, we have to actually hear them out. That’s my opinion. We have to hear them out. Yeah. So, tonight we’re going to tell you their story in as much detail as as we can. A real Boeing 767, a real captain, a real cockpit crew who barricaded themselves in with suitcases and a crash axe and passengers in first class who crash X. Crash axe. Yeah, like if you you can like cut out break yourself out of the wreckage something.
An emergency axe. There you go. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. um and passengers in first class who by every account the people who were sitting 20 feet from them were getting ready to do exactly what the other 19 men did that morning. And then at the very end, we’re going to tell you about the one man the government actually did catch in advance. So, it’s going to be about the fifth plane and then it’s going to be about the one person that was put on trial for 9/11, which was Zacharias Masawi. Mhm. Okay. Okay. And he was put on trial by the government like for the whole 911.
Okay. One guy. Yeah. That’s right. That’s the only one they have. [clears throat] Yeah. Uh United. That’s not true either. Yeah. [laughter] Okay. So, we know all the other flights. Now, this is the other one. United flight 23. H JFK to LA. Okay. It’s not 93. It’s 23. [clears throat] It’s a long flight. Yeah, it is. So, a Boeing 767. It’s the same aircraft as two of the other four. Yeah. Out of the same general wave of early morning flights that were transcontinental. Yep. So, most of those were Boston to LA. Yeah. Um, uh, Dulles to San Francisco. They’re all going they’re all long haul.
And you know that maybe that’s a maybe that was done on purpose. Yeah. Probably because the amount of fuel. Exactly. They’re going to be fully loaded to to make it that far. Yeah. And on that flight, uh, it was scheduled to leave around 9:00 a.m. similar. Yeah. A little bit later, actually. The other ones left a little bit more around 8 8:15, etc. Uh, there were roughly 160 passengers booked on it. And but see, this one’s coming out of JFK, though, so it’s like it’s already in New York. Yeah. In command, Captain Tom Manel. In the right seat, first officer Carol Timonss. Neither one of them had any reason pushing back from the gate that morning to think that this day was going to be any different.
Manela would say years later that it was a beautiful day, clear, calm, nothing unusual at all, except for one small thing. The ground crew doing the push back asked him almost kind of in passing, “Hey, did you hear anything about a fire at the World Trade Center?” Oh Yeah, he hadn’t. Captain Manilo. Nobody on the flight deck had. They taxied out and joined a line of roughly 10 aircraft waiting behind an Icelandic Air Airlines. All of them going nowhere because the entire airport had effectively stopped moving. Somewhere in that holding pattern of idling jets, Manelo heard that a plane had hit one of the towers.
And like almost everyone else in the country in that first stretch of confusion, he assumed it was something small and stupid. Yeah. Like accident. Yeah. Yeah. Had no idea sitting in that line of airplanes that the flight attendants working in the cabin behind him were already watching something that had nothing to do with the sky over Manhattan at all. At roughly 9:20 that morning, a United Airlines dispatcher named Ed Ballinger, the man responsible for the whole slate of transcontinental United flights that morning, including the two that had been hijacked, started sending out warnings to every flight still in the air on the ground under his watch.
Good. And you guys remember this? Yeah. It was like a little text message of Yeah. like beware of intrusion or be beware of of cabin. Yeah. You know, intrusion. Yeah. It it read beware any cockpit intrusion. Two aircraft have hit the World Trade Center. Manelo had described that moment. That message came through almost exactly the same way every time he’s told it ever since. Seared into his memory. He and Timonss looked at each other. Neither one of them said much more than a low, “Oh,” they both knew instantly what kind of morning it was. Manelo grabbed the crash axe kept on the flight deck. Timonss wedged their own luggage into the gap between the bulkhead and the cockpit door.
Not a lock, not a lever, just suitcases jammed in tight enough that in Manila’s own words, nobody was getting through that door without breaking it into pieces first. Good for these guys. A flight crew barricading themselves in with their own carry-on bags because in September of 2001, the cockpit door was not reinforced. Mhm. It wasn’t required to be. And then almost immediately after that message came through, one of the flight attendants called up to the cockpit with something that made it less abstract. And it said, “There are four young men sitting in first class.” Described in the retelling as Arab, and something about them, she said, felt unusual enough that she thought the captain should know.
H three flight attendants who have gone on the record over the years, most fully in 2023, described what they watched happen in front of that airplane while it sat on the ground that morning, meaning they were on the tarmac. Oh, they were still on the tarmac. Yeah, they were waiting in the line. Okay. I was wondering. I was actually Yeah, but they were supposed to take off at supposed to take off. Okay. [clears throat] Okay. Yeah, but then like obviously there’s like a Well, there’s always delays at JFK. Jesus. That’s a great point. Honestly, JFK is one of the worst. It is. Yeah. Yeah. So, in first class, four passengers, two men, a young boy, and a fourth figure wearing what the crew described as a burka or a nab, a full facial and body covering.
More than one flight attendant independently noticed something about the fourth passenger that struck them as wrong. They had unusually large hands. LinkedIn is pretty amazing at helping you grow your small business. We cannot make your email response time faster. We can help you sell, market, and hire in one place. We cannot help you find space for your three desk drinks. Why do you have three? And while we can’t help you find the perfect volume for your presentation video, LinkedIn can help you find the perfect audience for your business. Grow your small business on LinkedIn. Learn more at linkedin.com/sallus. Oncology is a key focus for Fizer with 40% of R&D devoted to the oncology space.
Fiser is committed to advancing cancer care for your patients. Learn more at cancer.fiser.com. Yeah. How’s that? They’re like, “This is wrong.” Yeah. Hands that looked to them like a man’s hands. Meaning it was a woman wearing a burka. Oh, but the hands looked really large and it to them looked like a man disguised as a woman. Right. Right. Yeah. I see. I was wondering. I was like, “What?” Like, yeah. God, the people like when I go on a plane, they look at me like, “Look at this guy’s huge hands and feet.” Gross. Pat him down. Something’s wrong. More than one of them separately came away from that cabin believing they had just watched a man disguised as a woman sitting in the first class.
The group would not eat meat, and the galley that morning only had two fruit plates available. When the purser tried to find something else for them, one of the men in the group cut her off. They didn’t want food. He told her, “They didn’t need it. They just wanted to take off.” That was the whole request repeated more than once. Just go. Take off now. Yeah. Just get this plane in the air. So, you kind of see the timeline. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They seem a little delayed. They’re like, “Fuck.” They seem a little, you know what I mean? They’re sitting on the tarmac still. Oh, yeah.
Everybody knows that a a plane hit the tower and they know this is like they’re if this is the thing, right? Like they know that the other part of the plan’s already taking place like we need to get on the air now. Yeah. During this, one of the men asked if the little boy traveling with them could go up and see the cockpit. [clears throat] He was told no standard policy. Nobody but crew in the cockpit that morning. For reasons that had nothing to do with the particular request, one of the flight attendants says that not long after being turned down, she found the man and the boy standing at the cockpit door anyway, peering in trying to see what was happening.
Okay. If they really hijackers, did you bring a kid into this? You’re Wow. I mean, how how much lower can you go? No. And it’s a good point. It it it deviates from the other plans. Yeah. I don’t know. I know. So maybe I don’t know. We’ll see. Continue. I don’t want to jump to conclusions yet. None of this on its own proves anything though. People travel with children. People have dietary restrictions, especially in first class. People get impatient sitting on a tarmac. But three trained flight attendants independently watching the same four people came away from that morning with the same unsettling feeling. Yeah. Like usually it’s like one person’s like odd, but like why are like all these people odd?
And every one of them said in the years following that what they saw that day looks different now than it did in the moment once they learned what happened on 911. Okay. But I do feel like having a like sure like the kid could be your end of the cockpit, but then like then the kid’s just a liability. Mhm. Yeah. And it was like not the same plan as all the other ones that we know of. And also it’s like I’m sorry what kid like my daughter doesn’t listen to a word I say. I mean like I’m like there’s no compliance. Like she’s going to do whatever she wants to do.
But take take the compassion out of it. It it would make it easier for you to get through security. Oh yeah, true. It would make it less suspicious. Yeah, that’s true. You know, it almost seems like it that probably would have been a This sounds horrible, but a better plan for all of them if they recruited. It’s a more It’s an even if you can get more up. It It is. Yeah. Yeah. It is like knowingly bringing a child knowing that you’re going to do this. Do you remember the USS Cole bombing? Yeah. In some versions of those stories, there was a kid on the boat.
Oh, so they wouldn’t shoot the boat. Yeah. I mean, they gets psycho when that’s like Yeah. war times. Yeah. First class wasn’t the only place on that airplane where something felt off. Back in business class, one flight attendant, Sandy Thorn Grin, noticed a man in a t-shirt who was sweating profusely. I mean, that’s visibly despite sitting in a cabin that was by her account air conditioned. Look, that’s not that weird. That’s not that weird. I I Dude, I’m I was I’m sweating in my house. It’s 60 degrees and I’m like sweating. Sitting in that tarmac. There’s There’s the worst. I know. And when the engines are not revving Yeah.
Yeah. It’s like air conditioning doesn’t work. Yeah. That’s There’s no such thing as it’s air. There’s like maybe some air blowing. There’s no air conditioner. She’s also trained professional. Like we’re not trained for this Yeah. And it sounds weird, but we know it coming from Tampa because like for example, when we flew up to New York, Tampa is 85°. Mhm. And then New York is 55. So when we get on the plane, we’re wearing shorts or whatever. Or preparing to to land in coldness. And so the temperature gets wild, you know, like when you’re in it. So So Thorn Grin has been careful telling this story.
she to say explicitly that this wasn’t about where anybody was from or what they looked like. And she and I quote, she says, “We were not profiling. We sense something was wrong. There were red flags all over it.” And that’s the direct quote. Then during the actual deplaning, so the after the ground stop after the airport itself had been ordered to evacuate. Mhm. So it never took off. Yeah. But [clears throat] I also think like I think they’re also recounting this like after knowing what happened. Correct. And then you know like having additional data then makes things even feel feel even more sketch. Yeah. [clears throat] Correct.
So like whereas like if that didn’t happen they’d probably just like chalk it up to like whatever. Well there’s more. Okay. So we’ll see. Yeah. So after the actual deplaning, after the ground stop, after the airport itself had been ordered evacuated, Thor Grin says a passenger from business class turned to her and asked a question, which was, “Did they get the White House?” By the time United 23 was sitting at the gate getting evacuated, most passengers on the ground in New York knew two things. Two planes had hit the towers and something had happened at the Pentagon. So flight 93 was probably theoretically could have been Oh yeah.
meant for the White House, which we speculated. Or it could just be a a comment like you know that you know you’re basically under attack under siege. So like you would naturally think that they’re going to go for the White House. I would I mean I mean that that that is of extremely large especially after you hear the Pentagon. Yeah. If you heard like, “Oh my god, the Towers hit the Pentagon say like did they get the White Okay. Okay. Okay. Logical deductive reasoning here.” So whether the White House itself had actually been hit wasn’t common public knowledge at that exact moment. And they didn’t even know about United 93 Mhm.
um crashing in uh Pennsylvania. But theories abound that that’s the kind of detail you’d only ask if you knew about the plan. I mean, sure, yes and no. Like, like Cory was saying, it’s a Yeah, that is true. If you knew about the plan, you would ask that. But also, like the White House is the the most like if something happened right now, I would probably like we would be like, did they hit the you know? Yeah. Up in the cockpit. Manelo and Timonss had no way to taxi anywhere because the entire airport had gone still. And then the tower came on the radio with what Manila calls the strangest call he’s ever heard in his life.
The airport was officially closed. Everyone was ordered to evacuate the facility. And word for word he says on the radio it said, “You are on your own.” Jesus. Damn. Like worry, we cannot help you. Yeah. So he taxied back toward the terminal, passed a clear view of the smoke rising from lower Manhattan, and parked at gate two. A mechanic came aboard almost immediately and told them all to clear out. He had orders to lock the airplane up completely and leave it sealed. So everyone got off the plane. Passengers, crew, the four people in first class, the sweating man in business, everybody evacuated. They all funneled out into a terminal that was itself being emptied in a hurry.
And for a while, United 23 just sat there locked, empty on an airport that no longer had anyone in it. Okay. And then a strange part of this story, a flight attendant who asked not to be named. So take it for what it is. Sure. Yeah. Okay. one person’s account, uncorroborated by a second witness, but told by someone who was there, and ever since then has never changed her story. This is extreme. This seems extremely loose. Told by her cousin’s best friend’s husband, she says she went back onto the locked, supposedly empty aircraft alone to grab her bottle of water. Okay, sorry. When she stepped into the back alley, two men were standing there.
Not passengers she recognized from the flight. Men who, by her account, had been hiding on the airplane the entire time it sat locked at the gate. She says they looked her dead in the eye, turned their backs on her, and didn’t say a word, and that everything in her told her to run, so she ran. First of all, how did she get in? cuz she is the She has the skeleton key for this airplane to get her a water bottle. It’s I’m sorry. If it was like her purse. Okay. Yeah, you need that. It’s got your license, your I mean you you you need that.
No. my water bottle. Yeah. Let me go. Seems a little weird. Let me go unseal this sealed plane. Everybody knows now. Everybody told you to evacuate. Everybody knows that you got to evacuate. They know what’s going down. Okay. And you go back to get a water bottle. I know. It just seems weird to go back to get a water bottle. Seems a little odd. Yeah, it’s true. But like and also what are those homies going to do on a what if what if like that thing was the plane is sealed? Just die of like starvation in this plane like sealed inside this plane. So she says an FBI agent later told her that a mechanic confronted those men that she witnessed.
They pretended not to understand English. The mechanic locked himself inside the cockpit for his own safety. And the two men tore up a section of carpet and escaped through an access point into the aircraft’s electronics bay out of the plane entirely without ever going through the door. And I watched a video of a guy explaining how this specific plane and it’s very fast. Oh, meaning this and it’s a bit of an older plane, but if you know where the panels are, you can like So, right in front of the cockpit door, there’s a you lift up the carpet. It’s like a little hatch. There’s a hatch and then you jump down and there’s an electronics bay.
Yeah. And then you walk two or three steps and then there’s another hatch and you go at the bottom of the plane and that’s the bottom of the plane. Like you see it in bad movies. Yeah. I was Harrison Ford is going [laughter] up and down that shootute at all times. You know what I mean? What’s that one? Is it Commando? The one with uh uh Schwarzenegger and he like jumps off the plane and he like goes down that hatch and anyways [laughter] what he say like what is this guy’s name? He’s like my arm’s getting tired. [laughter] Remember when I said I’d save you for last?
I lied. I I might watch that movie tonight. Also, you remember the movie with uh Wesley Snipes, Passenger 57? Oh, yeah. Always bet on black. [laughter] Yeah. In the documentary that eventually told this part of the story, the crew adds one more detail that lines up with her account. Roughly 20 minutes after that plane had been locked up and declared empty, people on the ground reportedly saw two uniformed figures moving through the cabin. H. And when investigators checked the aircraft afterward, they found a floor hatch between the cabin and the lower electronics bay standing open. Ooh. Okay. So, I still don’t know what those guys would do with a plane that But that’s still interesting.
Yeah. Nobody has ever publicly identified who those two men were, how they got into a sealed aircraft, how they were uniformed, why were they why they were there, and where they went after they got off in Terasante. [clears throat] Maybe they were like removing evidence. That’s could Yeah, but then who is it? Like who do they work for? Well, I’m saying Well, they were Well, I don’t know. They were unformed. Maybe they were uh you know, I don’t know. on a mission. Now, there’s a [laughter] couple there’s a couple extra interesting parts of this. And at 11 11 a.m., a United Airlines employee called Port Authority Police to report three Arab men at the gate who were refusing to leave a canceled flight.
An officer was dispatched 17 minutes later. By the time he arrived, the men were gone. Are we talking about the same flight or a different flight? Same same airport. Same airport. Same plane. But yeah, like they But also like a fixed plane now. No, no, no. It’s the same. No, I’m just kidding. But we don’t That’s all the That’s all the data we have. We don’t know if it was a different flight. We don’t know if it was But it’s just another report side flanking the story, right, of that that they were pissed off that the flight got cancelled and then they disappeared. Yeah. But I but I I I do feel that my gets canceled.
I’m also like Yeah. You’re raging out. I’m trying to get like maximum bennies. Yeah. Like in the middle of war. Yeah. No, no, no, no, no, no. Okay. And a couple other things. 2 days after the attacks, four Saudi men were detained at JFK. Booked, according to the record, for a United flight to California. They told authorities they were simply trying to get a refund and rebook their travel. One of them was carrying an Embry Riddle aeronautical university ID. And Embry Riddle is one of the most prominent commercial pilot training schools in the country. Okay. Another was carrying a Mayo Clinic card. When it’s time to scale your business, it’s time for Shopify.
Get everything you need to grow the way you want. Like all the way. Stack more sales with the best converting checkout on the planet. Track your chuch-chings from every channel right in one spot and turn realtime reporting into big-time opportunities. Take your business to a whole new level. Switch to Shopify. Start your free trial today. Oncology is a key focus for Fizer. With 40% of R&D devoted to the oncology space, Fizer is committed to advancing cancer care for your patients. Learn more at cancer.fiser.com. I don’t know the re I don’t know the relevance of that, but okay. That’s just the data, right? The FBI wrote up a formal report, a 302 report on each one of them.
All four names remain redacted to this day. Interesting. Manelo, the the captain, says he later heard on CNN that the four men had been released because investigators concluded they weren’t actually involved. Yeah. But at this at this time too, it’s like any like even vaguely suspicious Arab individual is like everyone’s like totally everybody you see I remember like remotely Pakistan you’re like you look Indian you look anything other than I remember going to Kroger this cuz I was in Ohio and this happened [laughter] and then like seeing like an Arab dude I was like oh god even Sean got stopped. No they were like he’s Mexican don’t worry.
[laughter] Yeah, he’s a facial friendly. So, apparently the FBI took it seriously somewhat to put both the cockpit crew and the cabin crew through extensive questioning. Manelo described an interview that ran about 4 hours. Holy At one point, he says an agent told him directly that there had actually been seven Arab or Muslim individuals connected to the flight who the bureau were looking at. Three of them, a family, a couple traveling with a toddler who were cleared almost immediately. The other four, the agent told him, were the ones they were still trying to find. Manelo says he never heard another word about it. Never got another interview by the FBI.
No follow-up call, no resolution, never heard from them again, actually. Manel, interesting. Okay. Yeah. The cabin crew went through something similar. Thorn Gren says the FBI interviewed them individually, one at a time, at their hotel the night of 911. The next morning, she says agents drove them in a windowless van to a lineup at Port Authority facilities to see if they could identify anyone. Nobody in the lineup that they that they were shown matched the people that were on the plane. Okay. M Carol Timmons who was the first officer and she unfortunately passed away uh later uh so we don’t have the ability to like question her f further.
Um she put it plainly and she says the FBI asks questions but they don’t tell you things. No, because they’re they’re trying to and they obviously they separate you. They want to they want to make sure the stories line up. There’s like a whole Yeah. whole gambit that they do know. And here’s where it gets even weirder. A few days after the attacks, Minnelo, the captain, got a call from a chief pilot at one of United’s flight operations offices, and he asked him for the specific tail number of the aircraft he had been flying on 911. His plane’s fleet number ended 6002. Nearby there was another 767 numbered 6001.
That man on the phone he told the captain that box cutters were found at on 6001. Oo not his plane. Yeah. But the like the next in the line one park that was next to it. Interesting. Manelo has been honest about how he reads that detail and I quote. He says, “If somebody was on the ground cooperating with these hijackers, they just simply made a mistake and put the box cutters on the wrong plane.” [clears throat] But even but even so, like what? Like or they just like threw them when they were getting evacuated like get rid of this. Yeah. Stash it on the plane.
Like why why keep it with you? But you get what Manella is saying, right? Is that he had four suspicious people. They wanted to get up and then that somebody was was on the ground helping these hijackers. I see. And they put the box cutters on the planes. But this one, they put it on the wrong plane. Oh, so you’re saying that you’re saying that like all of the hijackers, they had their box cutters planted so they could just get them while they were there. But I thought you could take a box cutter on a plane at this time. So maybe just to make them maybe it’s to make them even less like not to any sort of suspicion or Yeah.
And maybe they were scared they were going to get caught and so they’re like we need somebody on the inside. We need a baggage handler. Yeah. But I mean you’re talking about several I know for every plan. See how it just leads this is this would this would change everything because that means you have more conspirators. Yeah. But but my thing is like if you were if you were able to have someone on the inside like why plant box cutters? Plant a gun. Like true. No, you’re going to get zero resistance with a gun. With a box cutter, a dude might like be like, you know what, it.
I’ll take my chances. Just don’t like to get the hand. Maybe not get stabbed. Well, maybe cuz whoever’s helping them like they got to get the guns through their security. That’s a good point. And it’s easier especially if they’re part of like the crew. Yeah. Like mechanical. They’re like, “Yeah, it.” That’s a good point. That’s a good point. I mean, but but yeah, that changes everything cuz that means every plane would have had somebody. Yeah. So there’s a whole another people who are out there still. Yeah. I mean, but this is honestly this is his theory. This is his theory. Yeah. It’s for a few years after the attacks, this story surfaces only in fragments.
In 2002, NORAD’s deputy commander, Lieutenant General Ken Penny, told a reporter that the military suspected there might have been more than just the four aircraft involved in the plot that morning. Mhm. an admission from someone inside the actual air defense chain of command. Though he never named United 23 specifically, it is on record saying that they suspected another plane. I mean, rightfully so. I would also suspect suspect that that same year, Illinois Congressman Mark Kirk said publicly that the suspicious passengers from that flight had never been found and were, in his words, likely still at large. Then in July of 2004, the 9/11 Commission released its 400page final report.
the single most authoritative government account of the entire day. United Flight 23 is not mentioned in it once. A staffer who worked on the commission asked about it years later said the broader plot it does not have room for a fifth plane. What the Yeah, man. I mean, we don’t have space for this. They were just so focused on what act like the big thing that happened because uh how do we cover it up? They also needed finality too. Like we needed to we needed like a a close clean cut. They they just wanted to get over there. Yeah, for sure. Get the boys over there.
Anyways, we’ll get into that. The fullest account of this entire story for most of two decades existed only in a single chapter of a 2008 book called Touching History, written by a pilot named Lynn Spencer, who sourced her version, The Box Cutters: The Handwritten Al Qaeda Instruction Sheets Found reportedly in unclaimed baggage to FAA and airport officials. It was never officially confirmed on the record anywhere else. Then in March of 2023, TMZ, which I don’t like TMZ in any way, shape, or form, and that’s just my own personal preference, okay? But they aired a documentary called TMZ Investigates 911, the fifth plane, and they did a six-month investigation that for the first time put Manelo Ballinger and three of the flight attendants on camera together telling their side of the story.
I don’t know. You just kind of downgraded it for me. TMZ is like tabloid. TMZ is like the lowest form of reporting that I think exists. So, in that documentary, and I I did watch it, uh, Manelo says, and I quote, “I now believe that is more likely than not that we were the fifth airplane.” I mean, look, it’s he’s a pilot. No, but I’m saying like it’s just it’s just super loose. Like, there’s Mhm. There’s nothing even like remotely definitive that I can because I’m I’m looking for I’m looking for something to grab on to. Like I want trust me I am I want to Yeah.
And it’s totally possible. I’m not saying it’s like impossible but it’s just it’s all speculation and they’re also you know to quote one of our favorite peeps, you know, they’re looking at through the lens of of the prism the the prism of like after the fact. And so obviously it’s like, you know, it’s like I do something, you know, I make a up at work and then like I look back on it, I’m like, “Ah shit.” You know, like I knew this was a red flag. Why didn’t I see this or this or that, you know, like whatever. It’s like hindsight’s 2020. So it’s it’s easy to look back and be like, “Oh, okay.
These things seem weirder now that I know what happened.” Yeah. And like the extent of like the the death and like the destruction that occurred, I just I don’t know. I just think it’s like it’s just so speculative. So, the last part of this before we get into the trial is that um and it’s strange, the FBI confirms in writing that files on United Flight 23 do exist. See, that’s why that that to me is the weirdest part. Like, why are they like, “Yeah, not like you think they would just be like, “There’s nothing. Just release that.” In July of 2023, after a Florida bulldog reporter filed a formal records request, the FBI’s own acting section chief wrote back and refused to release them and citing quote a pending or prospective law enforcement proceeding end quote and stating that releasing the information could reasonably be expected to interfere with the investigation.
It’s like the loophole. Mhm. It’s 2023. So, what investigation are we still doing? That’s what I’m saying. It’s like a loophole. You keep it open as like a cold case. It’s still technically pending. Yeah. Mhm. Well, if it’s 2023, then this post Patriot Act, too. And there’s so much that they can there’s there’s so many loopholes like the Freedom of Information Act is like it’s it’s great and it’s cool, but there’s a lot of ways around it. Yeah. And also, the Boston Herald got the same response. So, it wasn’t just one report. Everything’s national security now. No, it’s just [clears throat] you you can’t get access to anything.
So, and I just even though you’re supposed to with with the Exactly. But but like I said, there’s there’s a there’s an infinite amount of loopholes. Yeah. And I just think it’s pretty wild because 22 years after the attacks, the federal government is on record stating that there is an active ongoing unresolved law enforcement matter connected to United Flight 23. Yeah, that’s that’s weird. Yeah, that’s weird to me. It’s still unresolved today. Yeah. May like Yeah. See that? That that alone makes me feel like, okay, maybe there’s something here. Yeah. Like otherwise, why wouldn’t they just be like, it’s nothing like because they never caught these guys.
And that’s why it’s still an ongoing investigation. Therefore, you can’t know anything about it. And also, it’s national security. So, go away. I know. It just seems so that like that to me is so sus. M. So, the next section of this is the trial, and it’s the only person that has been put on trial for 9/11. Um, and I thought it was appropriate that it’s one of our last things that we go over. Yeah. Before we um give it a summation. Yeah. Exactly. So while that story was unfolding at a gate in JFK, there was exactly one person connected to this plot who the US government actually did catch in advance.
His name was Zacharias Masawi and the government spent the better part of 5 years deciding what to do with him. Masawi was a French citizen of Moroccan descent, radicalized over the course of the ‘9s after moving to London. He trained in al-Qaeda camps in Afghanistan and personally approached by Osama bin Laden himself for an attack on American soil. In August of 2001, he enrolled at the Panama International Flight Academy in Minnesota, not to learn how to fly a plane from the ground up, but to train specifically on a Boeing 747 simulator. Despite having no pilot’s license and barely 50 hours of actual flight time to his name, and none of it was solo, so was always with a partner.
Yeah. His instructors found him deeply strange. He paid roughly $7,000 in cash. He said he wanted the training as something close to an ego boost, a joy ride. [snorts] Okay. He showed particular specific interest in the aircraft in the aircraft’s autopilot system and seemed fixated on the cockpit doors, visibly surprised to learn they couldn’t be opened midflight. Interesting. On August 15th, 2001, flight school staff called the FBI. The next day, the FBI arrested him for overstaying his visa. Got him, sucker. What happened next is one of the most consequential intelligence failures in the entire leadup to 9/11. FBI agents in Minneapolis wanted to search his laptop and his belongings immediately.
They believed that he was an Islamic extremist preparing for some kind of attack. They were right. FBI headquarters in Washington refused to authorize the warrant, arguing there wasn’t enough evidence to tie him to a recognized foreign terrorist organization under the legal standard that was required at the time. See, this is where it’s like, see, they’re like, “Yeah, see, we need we need more latitude. We need more ability to see what I’m saying. Like the request got bogged down, edited, sent back, second guessed, and ultimately denied. By the time agents finally got a criminal search warrant for his belongings, it was on the afternoon of 911.
The 911 the 911 commission’s own final verdict on this was careful. A maximum investigative effort, the commission wrote, conceivably could have uncovered Msawi’s financial connections to Ramsey, one of the actual 9/11 plots central coordinators. And those connections might have led the investigators to the heart of the operation itself. And just as significantly, the commission noted the mere publicity of Masawi’s arrest and a possible hijacking threat might have spooked al-Qaeda into calling the entire thing off. Oncology is a key focus for Fizer with 40% of R&D devoted to the oncology space. Fizer is committed to advancing cancer care for your patients. Learn more at cancer.fiser.com. Breathe in now.
Let it all out with Lincoln Rejuvenate, a multiensory feature available in the 2027 Navigator SUV. Experience a gentle massage, expansive visuals, and digital sense to help you relax in the driver’s seat. It’s your time for a reset. Visit lincoln.com to learn more. Lincoln Rejuvenate does not operate unless the vehicle’s in park when the vehicle is off or if any door is open. Do not use the feature in a closed garage or another enclosed area. See owner’s manual for important operating instructions. Okay. Okay. All right. [snorts] Messiah was formally indicted on in December on six conspiracy charges tied to 9/11. Four of them carrying the possibility of a death sentence.
But like did they find any like pl like plans or like manuscript manifesto like anything? What followed was one of the strangest, most combative criminal trials in American history. He fired his own lawyers and represented himself for most of the two years. That is such a terrible idea. This is a really bad idea. He filed furious and often incoherent handwritten motions. And at one point he tried to plead plead guilty and he declared an open court and I quote, “I have knowledge and I participated in al-Qaeda.” and the judge refused to accept it. In April of 2005, he finally entered a formal guilty plea to all six counts.
At his plea hearing, he described being part of an entirely separate later plot to fly a plane into the White House to force the release of a convicted terrorist, the so-called blind chic Omar Abdel Brahman. He specifically denied at that point having any role in 9/11 themselves. So he was trying to plead guilty to like a future conspiracy. Yeah. For the to fly into the White House. Yeah. Then in March of 2006, during the sentencing phase of his trial, Masawi took the stand against the explicit advice of his own defense attorneys and said something new. He testified that he and convicted shoe bomber Richard Reid had been assigned to hijack a fifth plane on the 9 on 911 itself and fly it directly into the White House.
He said he lied to the FBI during his August 2001 arrest specifically so the attacks could go forward without intervention. He had never once in any prior statement claimed a direct operational link to Reed. Intelligence officials who had spent years studying the 9/11 plot were openly skeptical. And 6 weeks later on May 8th, 2006, Masawi himself asked to withdraw his guilty plea entirely. Jesus, this guy is all over the place. Telling the court that his White House testimony had been, in his own words, a complete fabrication. The judge denied that request as well. The jury that decided his sentence took all of this into account.
And when the verdict form came back in May of 2006, several jurors had written in specifically that Masawi had only limited knowledge of the 9/11 plans. Not one single juror found his fifth plain testimony reliable. And in the end, the jury could not unanimously agree to sentence him to death. So, he received life in prison without the possibility of a parole, which honestly seems worse. And it makes him to this day the only person ever convicted in the United States civilian courtroom in connection with 9/11. Yeah, it’s bizarre that he was like all over the place. And to this day, he is held in the federal supermax in Colorado.
H surprising other ones in Guantanamo. Yeah, I’m surprised he hasn’t been shived. I know. I’m surprised. I’m very surprised he has not been like Are you sure he’s still alive? They’re like on paper he’s alive. [laughter] Like he’s been dead for like 20 years. Like So that’s where that leaves us. The one man the government actually caught in advance. The one who had real documented ties to al-Qaeda. who trained in a Boeing 747 simulator for reasons that made no sense for a man with no pilot’s license, stood up under oath in a federal courtroom and claimed to be the fifth plane hijacker. He then retracted it 6 weeks later and nobody, including the jury, believed him.
Then there’s United 23, a real airplane, a real captain, and a real first officer who barricaded their own cockpit with suitcases because it’s all they had. Three flight attendants who independently came away convinced they just watched a man disguised as a woman. And three other passengers preparing to do exactly what happened on four other planes that same morning on September 11th. an FBI investigation serious enough that more than 20 years later, the bureau is still in writing calling it an active investigation and it cannot discuss with the public. So, we have two different stories. One with a confession that collapsed under its own weight. One with no confession, just a locked airplane, a few missing men, and a government that has never, not once in 25 years, told the people who were actually there and what it found on United 23.
And that’s where we’re going to leave it tonight. I I hope we’ve covered almost everything that we could cover. Yeah. related to 911 and the theories, the the data, the 911 commission, uh everything, you know what I mean? Like everything that we’ve we’ve got and I know we’ve got some flak for it being long. Um but you know what I mean? I I if it is I mean I hope it’s one of the more thorough I mean we got a little bit of flack on that but we got a lot of good things guy some people are like oh we’re like milking it for like all it it’s dude it’s this is the this is the worst terror attack in in our history like I think it deserves and I and it’s also like one of the most like recent ones that we can have access to a lot of data a lot of information yeah I I’m also excited for the compilation of it.
Oh yeah, for sure. That’ll be it’ll be like eight hours. 10 almost 10. Yeah, if we did it all in one thing, you know what I mean? So there you go, guys. I don’t know. What do you guys think about the the fifth plane? I mean, I think it’s Zachariah. It’s definitely it it it’s a little more plausible than I initially thought just because of the the because of only two things because the FBI still has it open. Yeah. 20 plus years later as an active investigation. Yeah. Cuz one would think that if there was nothing they would just close it just get it get rid of it.
And B that the it’s it’s loose. The rest of it’s super loose, but like the fact that they did see there was people leaving the plane after everything was locked down. Yeah. And like I I don’t know. I mean that I I it’s really just [clears throat] them. The fact that the case is still open makes me believe like okay, maybe there is something there. Yeah. Maybe like they they think that it was more plausible than like how how loosey goosey it was. But on the same vein, it’s like Yeah. I mean, of course everything’s going to be sketch as to you. Like, especially after the fact, like Yeah.
Like you were saying 20 hindsight 2020. Yeah. And you’re like, “Oh, these guys were definitely these guys were definitely nervous. They were sketchy. They were dressed different. They talked different.” I don’t know. Anything different. And it’s like, yeah. So, so the chick had like a normally large hands like, you know, not everyone’s a winner. [laughter] It’s a genetic lottery. I do I do I did want to do it because I want to give the the pilot Yeah. credit or at least give them the audience. Yeah. Meaning like we should hear him out. Same with the the flight attendants. Of course. You know, 100%. These guys do this for a living.
And it’s not like it’s not like there’s not anything to go off of, you know? It’s not like uh super ultra fringe Just because it wasn’t in the commission and all and in the media and it doesn’t mean that it’s less. I I actually think uh very possible. It could have been even more Yeah. I mean, there could have been 20 for all we know. It could have been like a whole but then they got grounded and blah. You know, there’s all these there’s all these existential circumstances you can’t control. Like you can’t control the flight patterns, you can’t control delays. Yeah. Yeah. You know, like I just flew to New York and it was like I was flying back and they had to f there was like mechanical issues with the plane and my flight left an hour late and so I was like, “Oh, back to the bar.” [laughter] Do you think there’s anything to the the the other guy who called and said he found box cutters on a plane that was I mean I like I was saying I think that there could have been just somebody that like just stashed them away or like just they just wanted to get rid of them in case they were going to get search or something on their way out.
So that kind of brings me back to my point that it’s very possible that there’s even more than this fifth plane. Um, I think it was kind of like a a I mean I think it was maybe even part of the plan but also like a redundancy like they knew like okay if one or two you know get get caught we have other ones in play. Yeah. That that’s why I think you have so many. It’s like you have Yeah. Like the redundancy factor. It’s like but that would mean that it’s real. M even if it was a redundancy, you you still had back. Just because it’s not in the commission or it wasn’t in like the the general story, the media and all, you know what I mean?
Like just because we don’t know so much about it doesn’t make it less doesn’t make it not real. Yeah. Yeah. No, for sure. I can I can get behind that. And yeah, I just I have a hard like once it gets starts once the conspiracy expands into like having so many moving parts and it becomes more and more unrealistic because Yeah. Like most of if you’re going to execute something like this, you need the as little people as possible. Yeah. Because then you’re you’re you’re adding in variables that can up. Yeah. like and then you know like the Minneapolis guy and you know he had the plans in his laptop and that could have led to the whole thing just being Yeah.
Yeah. Exactly. So you make one mistake. That’s why when I’m like okay when it’s like all right there’s homies on the ground like sure it’s possible but I don’t know if you’re going to want like that like more and more and more and more people involved in this massive conspiracy. Like yeah that’s why when I think when I get into like my summations you know it’s I don’t think it’s like some huge massive like and I and I even explain you’ll see we’ll explain it. So but two questions on this topic specifically one is if this were were true that means there are people who are still out there.
If that one part is true, if that there were in the uh the the the people helping with the box cutters. Yeah. Do you think that’s possible? Oh, for sure. Possible that they’re still Yeah. I mean, are they in America? They’re not hijackers. They weren’t hijackers, but they were Well, they were they were attempting. Yeah, they were almost No, no. I mean, but that means I’m saying the people who placed them. Oh, for sure. Do you think there’s Oh, do you people who helped who didn’t hijack a plane but they helped that are still out there? All right, remove yourself from this. Like just for one second like do you really believe that there’s not active agents of other governments of every almost every other government in the general populace as we speak right now.
Right. 100 without a shadow of a doubt 1,000% accuracy. There is agents of other countries here right now living seemingly seemingly regular lives. Yeah. Just getting intel or trying to influence people trying to do It’s happening. We’re doing the same over there. Like it’s it’s the game. Yeah. It’s happening. They’re there. They’re here. Yeah. They are like, let’s not be stupid. Like they’re here. Like we even talked or touched on that on I think it was what two episodes ago or whatever that there was the the dancing Israeli and they turn out to be intelligence and yeah oh that’s that’s definitely in my final summation I have I have an explanation for it no okay and then last question on this is um Zacharias the guy who was convicted I don’t even know what to think about this was he so this is the only guy who was convicted for 9/11 Mhm.
Correct. Or correct. Correct. Well, yeah. In the US. In the US. Yeah. Well, convicted. And we I’m obviously we killed. No. Was like Well, maybe we’ll talk to No. [laughter] Well, but there’s a whole bunch of them they caught and they took him to Guantanamo and they’re still there. That’s probably true. Yes. Yeah. 100% true. So, do you think that it was a legitimate conviction and then there’s just more out there? I think you could have convicted that guy with no evidence. I mean, why would why would he represent himself? That’s a that’s a death sentence right there. But he also was like all over the place.
Oh, I’m guilty. I’m not guilty. Wait, I’m guilty for a different thing. I’m not guilty again. I’m guilty. Never ending just trying to get out of it. I just I’m like, what is this guy? I think he was [clears throat] trying to drag it out like just like stay at like it just he’s I don’t know about that guy. Yeah, honestly. I really He’s too low level player part of it though. I think so. Maybe it’s a guy who maybe he maybe he was like tertiary involved and like not really like part of like the main plan, but he wanted like the clout and like the to feel like he was important.
Also, I could see the government being we need a conviction. No, they need somebody. They need somebody. We need Yeah, we need That’s what I’m saying. You could have convicted that guy with no evidence, but you probably could have convicted other others, too. I’m I’m sure that they could have found something. So, I don’t know. I just Yeah. I mean, I just think this guy up. He had he he made a mistake. He got caught and of course he’s going to get convicted cuz he was definitely part of it and yeah they’re going to need somebody to put a head on a pike. You know it’s like we got someone especially you don’t have Bin Laden yet cuz that’s another episode we’re going to go into whole hunt for Bin Laden and all that.
Yeah. Anyways, that one’s cool. Yeah. Or I mean I don’t want to say it’s cool. That one’s a very interesting episode. Yeah. Yeah. So there you go guys. That is the episode tonight. Um stay tuned, subscribe. Uh our next episode is going to be our final 911 summations. Uh where each of us will take a moment uh un unargued and just let us tell the opinion that we have after studying all of this. And um that’s going to be next Tuesday. So definitely tune in for that. And thanks for thanks for uh you know obviously being along for the ride. We know this has obviously been a very long series, but it’s important that we covered everything.
Yeah, absolutely. So, we’ll catch you next week on the Conspiracy Podcast. Night.
